Is anybody using vrrp ?

I keep getting "vrrpd_process_vrrp(vrrptst2vn0) unsupported version 2"

I vaguely remember getting it working a few years ago

But can't get it to work now

we expect vrrp version 3, the packet you recevied from the other end claims version 2

we seem to have expected version 3 since vrrp appeared

so I don't know sjorge, sorry :\

Both sides are illumos

On the same omnios bloody release

Hmm there is a CARP vip on the same subnet between 2 FreeBSD hosts

But different VID

Yeah, I definitely don't have ideas there. I just looked at the code were we were checking, and what we were checking.

I don't know how this works well enough to know if sharing a broadcast domain with carp could confuse it

but I can't find anywhere anything changed even a bit recently

CARP and VRRP IIRC use the same underlying mac ranges.

CARP and VRRP use the same IP protocol number (112)

I would not be surprised if the very last sentence, about them cooperating if care is taken, was false with our implementation.

sjorge: congratulations, you found a minefield? :)

sjorge: looks like it's just noise? it checks the protocol version and logs the error before it looks at the virtual router id.

could be just noise, but my vip between both zones stays in init state and that was the only clue

Not that there is a man page to go of on though

You have a good chance of finding (parts of?) a manual in the ARC materials

Arc materials?

fenix: PSARC 2009/388?

OpenSolaris ARC Material Archive PSARC/2009/388: VRRP Update (Published)

↳ illumos.org/opensolaris/ARChive/PSARC/2009/388/index.html

fenix: PSARC 2008/693?

OpenSolaris ARC Material Archive PSARC/2008/693: VRRP (Published)

↳ illumos.org/opensolaris/ARChive/PSARC/2008/693/index.html

should both have draft manuals and design docs in them

I’ll look around in there when I am more awake to

Morrow

usually with very unclear licenses, but if you ever feel inspired to clean-room some manual pages...

anyway, I wanted to quickly reply to a e-mail so I had a look at the links... some do indeed seem to have some man pages, but they do not seem close to the commands we ship.

wait, the 2nd one might be closer