19:20:08 <sjorge> Is anybody using vrrp ?
19:20:13 <sjorge> I keep getting "vrrpd_process_vrrp(vrrptst2vn0) unsupported version 2"
19:20:20 <sjorge> I vaguely remember getting it working a few years ago
19:20:24 <sjorge> But can't get it to work now
19:38:11 <richlowe> we expect vrrp version 3, the packet you recevied from the other end claims version 2
19:38:58 <richlowe> we seem to have expected version 3 since vrrp appeared
19:39:07 <richlowe> so I don't know sjorge, sorry :\
20:48:06 <sjorge> Both sides are illumos
20:48:21 <sjorge> On the same omnios bloody release
20:49:05 <sjorge> Hmm there is a CARP vip on the same subnet between 2 FreeBSD hosts
20:49:14 <sjorge> But different VID
20:50:15 <richlowe> Yeah, I definitely don't have ideas there.  I just looked at the code were we were checking, and what we were checking.
20:50:42 <richlowe> I don't know how this works well enough to know if sharing a broadcast domain with carp could confuse it
20:51:07 <richlowe> but I can't find anywhere anything changed even a bit recently
20:52:01 <rmustacc> CARP and VRRP IIRC use the same underlying mac ranges.
21:02:52 <sommerfeld> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Address_Redundancy_Protocol#Incompatability_with_IETF_standards
21:03:17 <sommerfeld> CARP and VRRP use the same IP protocol number (112)
21:04:31 <richlowe> I would not be surprised if the very last sentence, about them cooperating if care is taken, was false with our implementation.
21:05:03 <richlowe> sjorge: congratulations, you found a minefield? :)
21:07:24 <sommerfeld> sjorge: looks like it's just noise?   it checks the protocol version and logs the error before it looks at the virtual router id.
22:23:21 <sjorge> could be just noise, but my vip between both zones stays in init state and that was the only clue
22:23:40 <sjorge> Not that there is a man page to go of on though
22:24:18 <richlowe> You have a good chance of finding (parts of?) a manual in the ARC materials
22:24:33 <sjorge> Arc materials?
22:24:41 <richlowe> fenix: PSARC 2009/388?
22:24:45 <fenix> OpenSolaris ARC Material Archive PSARC/2009/388: VRRP Update (Published)
22:24:45 <fenix> ↳ https://illumos.org/opensolaris/ARChive/PSARC/2009/388/index.html
22:25:02 <richlowe> fenix: PSARC 2008/693?
22:25:04 <fenix> OpenSolaris ARC Material Archive PSARC/2008/693: VRRP (Published)
22:25:04 <fenix> ↳ https://illumos.org/opensolaris/ARChive/PSARC/2008/693/index.html
22:25:16 <richlowe> should both have draft manuals and design docs in them
22:25:54 <sjorge> I’ll look around in there when I am more awake to
22:25:58 <sjorge> Morrow
22:26:05 <richlowe> usually with very unclear licenses, but if you ever feel inspired to clean-room some manual pages...
23:04:14 <sjorge> anyway, I wanted to quickly reply to a e-mail so I had a look at the links... some do indeed seem to have some man pages, but they do not seem close to the commands we ship.
23:05:05 <sjorge> wait, the 2nd one might be closer