kind of sucks that i had to have picked the worst usb drives ever to boot freebsd with :)

the supermicro 1u i have has two internal on board usb ports and i put 2 128GB pny usb drives in it that were low profile to mirror and they go ridiculously slow

I feel like I must have misunderstood. Did you say that you're mirroring USB thumb drives?

yes. usb drives for booting

i've had 2 usb drives in my fbsd nas for years :)

i'm not really sure what happened with these. maybe the pny usb drives are just garbage

I thought maybe you had committed some kind of awful crime and mirroring USB drives was your form of penance.

lol

it works fine for booting

You have more on them than just /boot ?

well.. unless you get pny drives i guess

no. zroot

mirrored

i've had a couple die on me before. just pop the broken one out, replace with a new one, zpool replace it, done

those were the sandisk fits .. the really low profile small ones

Is at least USB 3?

well. the drives are. the ancient 1u i have them in only has usb2 ports

i have a dom for my ancient isilon but i never had a chance to put it in and yank the SDs because i really don't want to play with the nas since it just works (tm)

s/SDs/USB drives

plus i'd lose redundancy since there is only 1 dom port :/

i need to get 2 that work in the 1u so i can install proxmox and migrate my jails and containers to the 1u so i could use the ryzen i'm currently using as a fbsd server

which is on an asrock x570d4u board with ecc and 2 nvmes

is there some way to use passthru with securelevel enabled?

Hi guys, my znc is still down

I changed the cable of Ethernet, but the problem is still there.. And I finally uploaded the output of ifconfig, and I will post it; hopefully someone help me :)

I really need help :(

I have a headset, when the computer is loading FreeBSD, starts to give high pitched noise or feedback when it gets detected. It has happened under multiple versions of FreeBSD and BSD variants so I assume it might be kernel  or kernel adjacent. Any thoughts or if I should create a bug report?

I hate cloudflare..

I can't use pastebin

bloated JS

AI bots here and there.. Internet is really dead

Sure. Internet is the parody horizon for darpa

Or CERN, conspiracy begins now XD

Here is it, please someone check

I am not using static IP, and I tried but no luck, also tried restarting the netif and much more.. still no luck :(

I'd call the "inet 0.0.0.0" line unusual, but otherwise ok

jgh: then my problem is just begin unlucky :(

I think the router is blocking me for some reason..

I rested it many times disabled security

can you ping the IRC server? traceroute? telnet the IRC port on the IRC server?

I can't even ping my router's ip..

Host is down

All of this happened after using pulseaudio..

*I begin using

I disabled from startup but no luck..

can you see the router in fdb table

and what address is in line: inet 0.0.0.0 netmask 0xff000000 broadcast 255.255.255.255

How is your interface configuration?

Wait let me check

pasiz: you mean rc.conf

Yes. But you said you are not using fixed ip?

so if dhcp, where the 0.0.0.0 is coming?

yeah

I don't know

can you tcpdump dhcp req -> offer

I want to mention that I am now connected using my sim card, and I need to disable it and reconnect using my ethernet cable; so I lose coneection and I talked to the owner of my znc.. he said fixing will take sometime. So please send me all the commands you need

before I move back to my Ethernet cable to test them

and I am using all-in-one ISP router

oh

for nearly 10 years now

can you verify with some other device that the router is working

yeah done it and it's working

and I used same cable and new cables, also Wifi

Is changing my MAC will fix it? like I can see that router is blocking only my device

your mac seems to belong to HP devices

So you cannot login to your router?

Direct wifi using USB adapter no luck.. It only works when I use hotspot (Want also to mention, that fix can't last; Bec. I borrowed someone's old smartphone, to test that. the only phones that I have is a really old landline phone from 60s, and my Nokia C2 cellphone)

pasiz: No

*C2-01

pasiz: Could it be the problem?

I will disconnect to try your commands..

Wait I will go to eat, so I will leave the IRC connected; If you want send anything.

Retrofan: just remove that 0.0.0.0 address, maybe you have a misconfigured jail or sth?

Back

divlamir: how could I do that?

I only configured pulseaudio in jail

but the problem lasts even I disable it

ifconfig bge0 inet 0.0.0.0 netmask 0xff000000 delete

what is the jail's IP ?

I will try it now

divlamir: it's a chroot jail

and now is disabled

Leaving..

Can you ping the router after removing the 0.0.0.0 address?

hrm, nextdns is blocking dpaste.com

Back

tested everything

inet 0.0.0.0 was no more there after I reconnected, so didn't do anything about that

Tcpdump give me that error "tcpdump: can't parse filter expression: syntax error"

With the output file empty

to monitor dhcp you need a filter like 'port 67 or port 68'

I think fdb described the real problem..

? (192.168.1.1) at (incomplete) on bge0 expired [ethernet]

? (192.168.1.4) at 10:60:4b:69:94:cc on bge0 permanent [ethernet]

I also get expired for my mac on the router page which I accessed on another machine

divlamir: ah, but how can monitor all ports

do you need static arp ?

*I

mzar: it's nor static

*not

I connect then I get a new IP, after that the router block me..

This after the block

I can't get what happens between them it's so fast.. I need to set something to monitor

so now you have a single address 192.168.1.4? No more 0.0.0.0 trash?

can you confirm?

yeah

Oh, no.. I read now on some blog RSS I subscribed to, that even notepad got AI now :(

"Even better replacing it with the one from Windows 8.1 or launch Windows 10 just completly screws up the OS."

It was good idea moving to Freebsd, but now Ethernet is not working :/

"I think fdb described the real problem.." Oh, that is ARP.. my bad

Back

.

Look like no hope, I rechecked all my confs and nothing strange

But I want to say that before what happened (I unplugged then re plugged the cable that day), the internet was lagging, even when I use another machine.. but now, with my computer blocked, connection is stable

As I remember that begin happenin when I started working on setting up Ubuntu debbootstrap jail

Are you sure you didn't assign the same IP address to that jail and something else?

same IP address of my machine

?

V_PauAmma_V: it's changeable DHCP

Can your DHCP server tell you which IP addresses it handed to which MAC addresses?

You mean router?

yeah

but it listed as something like expired

If your router is also your DHCP server, yes, that's what I meant.

yeha

mine is ISP all-in-one router

V_PauAmma_V:expired

I'm not sure what you mean. What is expired?

my ip

it dosen't want to renew it

I tried static also no luck

Hmm. Sounds like your router (hence, your ISP) may be the problem or part of it.

No

Bec. I rested it 3 times

disabled security and firewall, works with any other machine

I think it blocks me for something on my device, but I don't know what is

Then only think I have done that day is unplug my cable then re plug it

after that no internet just connected to router but blocked

is that 0.0.0.0 in ifconfig showing up a failed attempt of setting a default route?

it happened before nearly 2 months ago, but when unplug and re pluged again it many times, fixed the problem.. but tried that now, no luck (I have done that like 100 time)

Hence, "part of the problem". As in, you may have several things, on your router or on that specific machine, conntributing to the symptoms you observe. Does your router have a "reset/restart this port" command or menu option?

let me check

No, only rebooting the whole router

V_PauAmma_V: Done that many times

ridcully: 0.0.0.0 is gone now

and I think so

Have you tried using tcpdump (or wireshark, or another front-end to tcpdump, or another capture utility) to capture the traffic between that machine and your router? That may give you a clue why your router does whatever it does.

wireshark..

I will download it now

Especially relevant would be the DHCP and ARP traffic, I think.

also check arp in case it is duplicate ips

checked before..

no duplicate ips

? (192.168.1.1) at (incomplete) on bge0 expired [ethernet]

? (192.168.1.4) at 10:60:4b:69:94:cc on bge0 permanent [ethernet]

my router's ip listed as expired, and the router lists me expired also..

As I said, ARP and DHCP traffic capture may shed some light on the problem.

ops

it needs root access, and there is no X server running on root sid

*side

IN that case, you'll need to use tcpdump (with su or sudo or whatever) for capturing and saving, then wireshark to view the saved capture.

Ok

V_PauAmma_V: How could I monitor all ports using it

You mean "what tcpdump syntax to use for capturing"?

yeah all ports

not only spefic one

Hold on. I need to refresh my memory of tcpdump syntax.

Ok

heh

fixed it, now wireshark can capture on non-root ones

V_PauAmma_V: I will go now for testing it

V_PauAmma_V: dhcp4 is `udp and (port 67 or port 68 or port 69)` iirc

so for ARP + DHCP4 it's `arp or (udp and (port 67 or port 68 or port 69))`

and NDP + DHCP6 is ip6 and ((udp and (port 546 or port 547)) or (icmp6 and ((ip6[40] == 133) or (ip6[40] == 134))))

Thanks, but since they figured out how to use wireshark, I'll go with that.

I need to add the first one to my scratchpad

Back..

also found the problem

Good. What was it?

(speaking of wireshark, I remember when I wanted to use its GUI on Windows to monitor my FreeBSD router's WAN interface, PuTTY's plink works perfectly for that)

The Arp in wireshark was only saying after the connection "Who has 192.168.1.1? Tell 192.168.1.4"

But it not true!

Reversed

Oh I could see my IRC msg plain on wireshark..

I thought 192.168.1.4 was the address of bge0 on the machine having the problem.

it's my pc

and 192.168.1.1 is my router

Is it your PC that has the problem?

yeah

I am connected using sim card now

my pc ip was 192.168.1.4

I dunno this looks like there's no link

Retrofan, is your router replying to that ARP request?

I think it should be "Who has 192.168.1.4? Tell 192.168.1.1"

if you're dumping on your PC it should not be like that

your PC asks the host 192.168.1.1 to reply with its MAC address to 192.168.1.4

so [22:45:35] <Retrofan> The Arp in wireshark was only saying after the connection "Who has 192.168.1.1? Tell 192.168.1.4" is correct

or am I wrong?

Yeah, what Remilia said. Next question is whether your router answers to that.

(And what it answers.)

I would honestly like to know what `ifconfig` shows for media

on that interface

V_PauAmma_V: how could I reverse it?

Retrofan: is your PC the router?

you should only reverse it if 192.168.1.4 is the router

Remilia, that (ifconfig) would have been my next question. AFKing for a few minutes to wash dishes.

I'm not sure what you are doing, but once again, ARP who-has IP1 tell IP2 means 'Hello, I am IP2, and I want IP1 to tell me its MAC'

V_PauAmma_V: Back again, if you said something please repost it

It went off agian

I don't know why my connection is not stable now..

I set default gateway before but no luck..

Back.

Help please :(

Firewall is also disabled on my machine

should I disable it using /etc/sysctl.conf

V_PauAmma_V: Wait I will try something

Disconnect...

Retrofan, the next 2 questions are: 1- in that capture you have, did the router (192.168.1.4) reply to your PC and what, and 2- what "ifconfig bge0" (or whatever the interface on your PC attached to the same Ethernet as the router) show for "media" and status

XD

This the problem.. my router is not 192.168.1.4

it is 192.168.1.1

and my pc is 192.168.1.4

Yeah, I gotr confused or misremembered. Sorry.

No problem :)

Retrofan, the next 2 questions are: 1- in that capture you have, did the router (192.168.1.1) reply to your PC (.4) and what, and 2- what "ifconfig bge0" (or whatever the interface on your PC attached to the same Ethernet as the router) show for "media" and status

just laughing about the weird problem

my pc thinks himself is 192.168.1.1

and router is 192.168.1.4

which what it got from DHCP in begin

V_PauAmma_V: dpaste.com/DTMDEVJXR.txt

take a look at my ifconfig.. and forget about 0.0.0.0; it's not here anymore..

V_PauAmma_V: dpaste.com/DTMDEVJXR.txt

take a look at my ifconfig.. and forget about 0.0.0.0; it's not here anymore..

I resended it bec. I don't know if it send

*sent

"inet 192.168.1.5 netmask 0xffffff00 broadcast 192.168.1.255" Is that your most recent ifconfig?

(nore the ".5", which is neither .1 nor .4)

Back

V_PauAmma_V: dpaste.com/DTMDEVJXR.txt

take a look at my ifconfig.. and forget about 0.0.0.0; it's not here anymore..

I don't know I am disconnecting

*why

(nore the ".5", which is neither .1 nor .4)

"inet 192.168.1.5 netmask 0xffffff00 broadcast 192.168.1.255" Is that your most recent ifconfig?

No my current was same but with 192.168.1.4

inet 192.168.1.4 netmask 0xffffff00 broadcast 192.168.1.255

V_PauAmma_V: It changes bec. it's DHCP

media: Ethernet autoselect (100baseTX <full-duplex>)

status: active

OK. I'm still waiting for an answer to question 1 above.

Back

V_PauAmma_V: It changes bec. it's DHCP

inet 192.168.1.4 netmask 0xffffff00 broadcast 192.168.1.255

media: Ethernet autoselect (100baseTX <full-duplex>)

status: active

Yeah

I will send the dump

V_PauAmma_V: accept it..

Done. Had to remember how to use DCC. Hold on, trying to look.

Wait I uploaded it online

V_PauAmma_V: take a look

Looks like that Wireshark was lagging the connection now, I closed it..

Retrofan: and please keep in mind for the future that ARP who-has IP1 tell IP2 means 'Hello, I am IP2, and I want IP1 to tell me its MAC', in standard English order

Yeah

like in 'who has cookies? tell me'; you wouldn't say 'who has me? tell cookies'

so I do not understand why you wanted to reverse it

But as I can see any other connection is reversed

*on machine

I'm not sure what you mean

I mean on my hotspot was reversed

and any other machine I try

PC

ARP always works the same way

the 'tell' part is Target Protocol Address in the diagram

it's very literally the last field

Ok, but 192.168.1.4 is not IP1

I'm sorry, can you read again?

192.168.1.4 sends an ARP message: 'Who has the address 192.168.1.1 (router)? if you do, please tell 192.168.1.4, thanks'

Wait

So it's a public msg on the network?

it's ARP, Address Resolution Protocol

I'm looking at the capture, and I see repeated ARP requests (who-has) but no replies.

yeah

I was pinging 192.168.1.1

So it looks like your router is ignoring 192.168.1.4, for whatever reason.

if there's no traffic at all besides ARP who-has, maybe that router port is in a VLAN or something

yeah, I think it's a block

VLAN?

Remilia: filebin.net/slcz2egiu1wjrxql/dump.pcap

also some ISP routers, especially PON stuff, often have only one port available for your devices, with the other reserved for IPTV set top boxes

I do not need your capture from your PC sorry, it would not tell me anything about your router configuration

How could I get you router configuration?

I don't think it would help in any way

did you already try turning the router off and on? because if you did and it did not help, the port this PC is connected to is either in a VLAN or dead

unless there's some setting to disable ports

try a different port to see if it works

tbh trying a different port would be my first step

Remilia: I rested the router 3 times and restarted it 30 times, and changed the port 100 time

This problem is here for 2 weeks now

Tried all I know

boot your PC off liveUSB Linux, WinPE or something and test network there

maybe your NIC doesn't work well with the FreeBSD driver

It happened after I unplug then re plug the cable..

Also, happened a month ago.. fixed by changing the port.. but now no luck

Remilia: I think it will work

IF I changed the OS

NIC is working like a charm with freebsd

if it works in a different OS it is a driver issue

NIC is working like a charm with freebsd

*I think it will work

not really working

I never tested

but the problem happend when I just unpluged the cable

from router side

and cable is working well on any other machine

When you say you reset the router, do you mean you powered it off and on, or something else?

No, get it back to factory settings

3 times

I sincerely doubt your router blocks ports based on OS detection heuristics, so if there's carrier but no traffic whatsoever, the port (ports) is (are) dead, unless you have other wired devices that work

all wired devices works well

Also Wi-fi

evverything

if the same PC works with Linux Live USB then it's a NIC driver issue

wi-fi does not matter, it is a completely different thing

Have you tried turning it off and on? That's what Remilia was asking earlier, I think.

Remilia: I never tested that, just pretending..

V_PauAmma_V: +50 time

also if the PC gets an IP from the DHCP server when trying network boot it's also a NIC driver issue

network boot?

I am not doing that

I'm very sadly not telling you to do that or that you are doing that

I'm telling you that if BIOS network boot can obtain an IP over DHCP from the router but FreeBSD has no NIC traffic whatsoever, it's a NIC driver issue

I know that only strange and bizarre problems happens to me :~(

also check dmesg for errors from the driver

Remilia: No errors

checked before

then there's no point in continuing until you can confirm that your PC's NIC actually works

Driver works well

How?

how can you tell that the driver works well?

FWIW, I can see traffic that was captured from other hosts including to and from a Libera IRC server, so I'm not sure the driver is part of the problem.

oh

then that's out

I don't think that driver will broke form just unplug the cable without even rebooting the PC

*from

Remilia: The all internet connection even on Wi-fi was lagging when I connect from about a month before that problem happen

nice

When I started using debboostrab Jail

nice :?

:(

Last attempt..

The more I think of it, the more I'm convinced (part of) your problem is with your router or router port. I suggest you ask your ISP tech support for help, if you haven't already.

ISP tech XD

V_PauAmma_V: my ISP tech knowledge is same as 5 years old kid (Pretending if they even replied)..

If that's the case (which would sadly not surprise me), try another ISP with better tech support?

In my country tech support is like trash, and all other ISPs is just separate ones from the main I am using

*all support..

I will leave now; for my last attempt..